Alan Cumming and Ari Shapiro promise to hold nothing back in thoughtful but naughty cabaret
What do you get when an iconic actor teams up with an accomplished journalist to create an original cabaret? A show with a good lede.
“The first thing we say is really filthy,” teased Alan Cumming in an interview. The Tony, Olivier, and Emmy Award-winning performer is one half of Och and Oy! A Considered Cabaret, which Brampton On Stage will present at The Rose on March 21. His co-conspirator is Ari Shapiro, one of the hosts of NPR’s radio program All Things Considered and its associated podcast Consider This. In Och and Oy!, which premiered in 2019, Shapiro and Cumming intersperse classic songs with stories from their rollicking lives — and from their first moment on stage, they hold nothing back.
“I always say that cabaret is like a smorgasbord,” said Cumming. “You can turn on a sixpence. [It’s about] shocking you with the extremes of what might happen. I think we certainly live up to that.” Cumming should know: his name has been inextricably linked with the art form since he won a Tony Award for his performance as the louche emcee of a Weimar-era nightclub in the 1998 Broadway revival of Cabaret the musical.
In the same interview, Ari Shapiro explained what makes Och and Oy! a “considered cabaret.” “The concept that we started with for the show was that it would have the kind of deep, thoughtful, probing conversations that you might get from NPR,” he said, “along with the slightly bawdy, entertaining song and dance numbers that you would expect from an Alan Cumming show, and these would combine to create something delightful and original.”
Delightful, original, and considered — but not too considered. “I think when people see that I’m coming to [do] a show, they’re like, ‘Oh, God! I don’t want to go to a concert hall and hear about the news,’” said Shapiro. “I feel like I have to explicitly say, ‘this is a news-free zone.’”
If there’s an overarching theme to the evening, it’s “about being queer men,” said Cumming. “We’re an odd couple [onstage], and the show is about how much more we have in common than you might think. One of the things we have in common is our queerness, and being men of a certain age, and just how we manoeuvre our relationships and our desires in our lives. It’s refreshing, and slightly subversive, for two older [queer] men — ”
“I beg your pardon?” joked Shapiro.
“One!” replied Cumming. “No, [but for] two older men to be talking about that in a public way.”
Cumming and Shapiro have no shortage of stories to share: Each man is a multihyphenate in his own right. Both are authors of bestselling memoirs. Shapiro hosted the seventh season of reality TV show The Mole in 2024, while Cumming has won critical acclaim — and two Emmys — for his camptastic turn hosting The Traitors US. Outside of Och and Oy!, Shapiro regularly appears onstage as a guest singer with the band Pink Martini, while Cumming co-owns a permanent cabaret space in New York’s East Village, cheekily named Club Cumming. A proud Scotsman, he became the artistic director of Pitlochry Festival Theatre in Highland Perthshire this past January.
“Being able to use different muscle groups, different creative skills, different parts of my brain, keeps me nimble and challenged and stimulated,” said Shapiro. “I think that’s one of the reasons Alan and I get along so well: if we’re not being challenged, and we’re not a little bit afraid, then we get restless.”
Shapiro met Cumming in 2014 through a mutual friend, who took the journalist to the actor’s dressing room — “the original Club Cumming,” said Shapiro — during a remount of Cabaret at Studio 54. (The dressing room’s history has since been immortalized with a neon sign outside its window.)
“We started doing events together onstage,” Shapiro said. “We did [an onstage interview] for the 50th anniversary of the Stonewall Riots at a museum in Washington, DC. As we were walking off stage, Alan turned to me and said, ‘We have such a good rapport. We should make a show together.’ I said, ‘Don’t joke about that, because I will absolutely take you up on it.’”
Cumming, for his part, said his experience of being interviewed by Shapiro was what inspired him to make the offer. “Ari actually challenges and says, ‘Well, what do you mean by that?’” said Cumming. “I really love a conversation where it’s not just fluff. He’s engaged in a way that I like to be engaged, and we [make] a good kind of oddball combo.”
That combo is actually a trio: both artists stressed how much Och and Oy! depends on their third collaborator, musical director Henry Koperski. “[He’s] sweetness and light and joy and beauty and talent,” praised Shapiro. “Being able to go on adventures with Alan and Henry is one of the best parts of doing this show.”
This current adventure will take the collaborators to New Brunswick and Nova Scotia in addition to Ontario. “I’m so excited to go to bits of Canada that I’ve never been to,” said Cumming. “To go to Nova Scotia, and also to go to Fredericton.”
“I’m most excited about going to Nova Scotia,” said Cumming, “because it is, of course, the New Scotland. I have a primal connection to it.”
Och and Oy! A Considered Cabaret plays at The Rose on March 21, 2025. Tickets are available here.
Nathaniel Hanula-James
Nathaniel Hanula-James is a multidisciplinary theatre artist who has worked across Canada as a dramaturg, playwright, performer, and administrator.
LEARN MORE
iPhoto caption: Photos courtesy of Lighthouse Festival.
Lighthouse Festival shines a light on Canadian comedies this summer
“When you laugh with a character, you connect with their story,” says artistic director Jane Spence. “You have more empathy and compassion for whatever their journey is. I believe that humour opens us up to each other’s life experiences. It’s what connects us.”
iPhoto caption: Kamyar Pazandeh and Julia McLellan in 'Waitress.' Photo by Dahlia Katz.
Ahead of the musical’s upcoming run at Hamilton’s Theatre Aquarius, I spoke with the production’s props and scenic design department to find out how they’re making the pie magic happen.
iPhoto caption: Photo courtesy of York University.
“I think the fundamental issue is that the foundation of inequity is still intact,” says co-curator Mariló Nuñez. “If you think about when Canadian theatre was first established, the theatre we were watching and learning about was Eurocentric, Western theatre… We place everything against that [perceived] ideal. Until that changes, I don’t think we can really make a change.”
iPhoto caption: Photo by Szymon Lazewski.
“We are all coming from somewhere, and we all have ancestors, and we all have this profound connection with not just where we come from but who we come from,” says playwright-performer Martha Knight. “That’s really connected me to the piece and connected me with everybody I’ve worked with on this show.”
iPhoto caption: Promotional still for Citizen Pochsy (2003). Photo by Gary Mulcahey.
Pochsy’s back! At VideoCabaret, a Canadian underground theatre icon returns to Toronto
“There are opposites at play at all times — in the show, in the writing, in the performance,” says playwright-performer Karen Hines. “When something gets dark, Pochsy might be super light in the delivery of it. When she’s being facetious or giggly, it might even be as she’s destroying a species."
iPhoto caption: Photo by Colton Curtis Photography.
Genny Sermonia sweetens the pot as choreographer of Waitress
When Genny mentions that her brother Julius is part of the ensemble, I smell a story cooking — so I attend a rehearsal at the Grand Theatre to watch the duo in action.
iPhoto caption: Photos courtesy of Lighthouse Festival.
Lighthouse Festival shines a light on Canadian comedies this summer
“When you laugh with a character, you connect with their story,” says artistic director Jane Spence. “You have more empathy and compassion for whatever their journey is. I believe that humour opens us up to each other’s life experiences. It’s what connects us.”
iPhoto caption: Photo courtesy of York University.
“I think the fundamental issue is that the foundation of inequity is still intact,” says co-curator Mariló Nuñez. “If you think about when Canadian theatre was first established, the theatre we were watching and learning about was Eurocentric, Western theatre… We place everything against that [perceived] ideal. Until that changes, I don’t think we can really make a change.”
iPhoto caption: Photo of Ada Aguilar by Dahlia Katz.
Speaking in Draft: Ada Aguilar
“I'm really passionate about the role of stage management as social activism, and as a way to provide safety and support for a production and its people,” says Aguilar. “We put everything of ourselves into these productions, but we also have to be good to ourselves.”
iPhoto caption: Miriam Fernandes as the Storyteller, with Anaka Maharaj-Sandhu as Arjuna and Neil D'Souza as Krishna in Why Not Theatre’s Mahabharata (Shaw Festival, 2023). Photo by David Cooper. Set design by Lorenzo Savoini, costume design by Gillian Gallow, lighting design by Kevin Lamotte, projection design by Hana S. Kim.
For the creators of Why Not Theatre’s Mahabharata, nothing is more contemporary than an ancient epic
“I’ve been [telling] the company to embrace time as a collaborator,” says director Ravi Jain ahead of the show’s April run at Canadian Stage.
iPhoto caption: Photo courtesy of the CBC.
As the trade war rages on, CBC’s PlayME stays true to its mandate of platforming Canadian writers
“I think all five of these shows really help us plant a stake in saying who we are as Canadians,” says PlayME co-creator Chris Tolley.
iPhoto caption: Photo by Audrianna Martin Del Campo.
Speaking in Draft: Veronica Hortigüela and Annie Luján
“Toronto needs to take comedies more seriously,” says Luján. “Comedy is not making people laugh every few minutes. In my mind, if people aren’t peeing their pants, we didn’t work hard enough. I think we can raise the bar on how out-of-control laughing we can make an audience.”
Comments