REVIEW: What the Constitution Means to Me froths with urgency
iPhoto caption: What the Constitution Means to Me production still by Dahlia Katz.
This review contains mild spoilers of What the Constitution Means to Me at Soulpepper Theatre.
Before seeing this show, I’ll admit that I’d never thought very actively about the U.S. Constitution, despite growing up in the U.S. as an American citizen. I don’t remember taking a civics class in school, and before Friday night’s opening of What the Constitution Means to Me, my knowledge had remained at Schoolhouse Rock level.
American actor-turned-playwright Heidi Schreck, by contrast, has been a Constitution geek since her mid-teens, when she started debating that founding document in oratorical contests to earn money for university. In a doozy of a theatrical indie-to-blockbuster story, this autobiographical play about her relationship to the Constitution started out as a short piece for an East Village avant-garde variety night in 2007, turned into a full-length show in 2017, and ended up a Broadway hit in 2019.
Now that the play is having its Canadian premiere, involving no fewer than four Ontario theatres (co-producers are Soulpepper and Nightwood, in association with Necessary Angel and Talk is Free), one might reasonably ask what What the Constitution Means to Me means to us. Is this another instance of Canadian theatres producing American or British hits to appeal to their core audiences, even if the material may be slightly dated?
While the first part of that previous sentence has the ring of truth to me, the second half doesn’t: Thanks to a number of intertwining factors, the material feels timely. For this first production outside of the U.S., Shreck has localized the script, so that the focus swings in its final quarter to the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. This production was timed to run during the American Presidential election (I’m writing this review on Monday, November 4), and the fact that federal politics are also roiling on this side of the border adds a further sense of urgency.
All that said, and despite the surprisingly intimate nature of the material, I found myself more impressed than moved by Constitution. It’s one of those pieces that slowly reveals itself as theatrical premises strip away, and perhaps it’s the extra layers of distance and biography that for me kept the material at an emotional distance.
The play starts with actor Amy Rutherford introducing herself as Schreck; their physical likeness, down to a butter yellow blazer echoing the New York production (costuming by Ellie Koffman), encourages investment in this fiction. She then plays Heidi as a 15-year-old, hitting the debate hard in the American Legion Hall in her hometown of Wenatchee, Washington, observed by a uniformed Legionnaire (Damien Atkins) and an audience coached to understand itself as all-male and only occasionally smoking cigars.
There’s no credited set designer for the Legion Hall, evoked by a back wall of framed photos, red carpet, podium, flag, and a few onstage chairs. Kimberly Purtell’s lighting adds to the institutional atmosphere, warming up as the material gets closer to home.
The debates accomplish one of the play’s central tasks: Charming didacticism. As young Heidi talks her way through key passages, the audience learns about American history and about the ongoing work of citizens and governments to keep the Constitution alive through exchange of views, political action, and amendment.
A key to effective debating, the show tells us, is communicating your personal relationship to the given topic. Shreck embraces this premise by increasingly focusing on issues of women’s bodily autonomy. A discussion of the equal rights supposedly enshrined by Amendment 14 leads her to stories of her great-great-grandmother, who died of melancholia at age 36, having been shipped from Massachusetts to Seattle as a mail-order bride. She tells intimate stories about herself, her mother, and other female relatives, fragile yet indomitable women all.
About midway through the show, a theatrical layer peels back as Atkins starts playing himself, sharing that his real role is to support Heidi with “positive male energy” as she undertakes this soul-baring. And then another reveal when Rutherford sheds the Heidi guise and we swing into the final Canadianized passage, as real-life high school debater Gabriella King arrives onstage to verbally duke out the Charter with Rutherford.
When performing the show off-Broadway during the Brett Kavanaugh confirmation hearings, Schreck cried throughout, as did many spectators and critics. As previously noted, the U.S. election makes this a high-stakes moment, nor do we lack things to lose our shit about in Canadian politics and public life (in the Charter debate, Rutherford reminds us that Pierre Poilievre has said he’ll use the federal notwithstanding clause if elected PM). But the balance of the material is such that this production ends up feeling decidedly unfraught.
Under Weyni Mengesha’s well-paced direction, Rutherford performs with presence, deep empathy, and poise. Atkins and King, too, are well-cast and engaging. When called upon to interact, the opening night audience was warm and game. It was an enjoyable and educational evening of theatre, rather than a searing dive into intimate truths.
The show’s concept was lightning in a bottle for Schreck. A great potential outcome of this staging could be that a theatremaker of King’s generation grabs hold of the notion of a personal take on political systems and takes it in a new and unforeseen theatrical direction. There’s so much more to explore in what the Charter means to us.
What the Constitution Means to Me plays at the Young Centre for the Performing Arts through November 10. Tickets are available here.
Intermission reviews are independent and unrelated to Intermission’s partnered content. Learn more about Intermission’s partnership model here.
Karen Fricker
Karen Fricker is editorial advisor for Intermission magazine, adjunct professor of Dramatic Arts at Brock University, and a member of the Canadian Theatre Critics Association. She has worked as a critic in Toronto; London, UK; Dublin, Ireland; and New York City, and has a PhD in theatre studies from Trinity College, Dublin. Her book The Original Stage Productions of Robert Lepage: Making Theatre Global (Manchester University Press) was the winner of the 2022 Canadian Association for Theatre Research’s Ann Saddlemyer Award for the best book in English on a Canadian topic. Her research interests also include contemporary circus and the changing nature of theatre criticism in the digital age.
LEARN MORE
iPhoto caption: Adam Francis Proulx, Elm Reyes, Kay-Ann Ward in a Fringe promo photo by Joy Adeola.
REVIEWS: Toronto Fringe Festival 2025
This collection of Toronto Fringe Festival capsule reviews will be updated throughout the festival with writing from 20 different critics.
iPhoto caption: Masae Day, Landon Doak, and Michelle Fisk in 'The Wind Coming Over the Sea.' Photo by Lyon Smith.
REVIEW: A new Emma Donoghue musical takes root at the Blyth Festival
As a resident of southwestern Ontario, what struck me most is how deeply rooted in the region The Wind Coming Over the Sea feels. It's a lively reminder of the cultural inheritances that continue to shape the area today.
iPhoto caption: The cast of 'Major Barbara.' Photo by David Cooper.
REVIEW: Shaw Festival’s metatheatrical Major Barbara is sharp and subversive
Director Peter Hinton-Davis draws on a light smattering of Brechtian techniques — acknowledgements of artifice that enrich and vivify Major Barbara’s clash of morals.
iPhoto caption: The company of 'The Frogs.' Photo by Dahlia Katz.
Staged inches from the audience by director Griffin Hewitt, the show commendably captures the free-wheeling, anarchic spirit of the text. It’s a toad-ally great opportunity to see this rarity in the froggy flesh.
iPhoto caption: Jeff Lillico as Ralph with Yoshie Bancroft as Mitsue in 'Forgiveness.' Photo by David Hou.
REVIEW: Stratford Festival’s Forgiveness tells a deeply personal story on a sprawling scale
Presented in an increasingly tense political moment, Forgiveness resonates on a level that is part reflection, part warning.
iPhoto caption: Photo courtesy of Luminato Festival.
REVIEW: Is Tim Crouch’s An Oak Tree worth seeing twice at Luminato?
Crouch tests the limits of theatrical representation, improvisation, and authorship. While I’m usually a sucker for exactly those types of experiments, I ultimately found An Oak Tree a bit underwhelming.
iPhoto caption: Philip Myers as Mamillius (left) and Lucy Peacock as Time in 'The Winter's Tale.' Photo by David Hou.
Stratford Festival reviews: The Winter’s Tale and Anne of Green Gables
A winter story told by a melancholy child and a fanatical Lucy Maud Montgomery book club help frame the final two productions in the Stratford Festival’s 2025 opening week.
iPhoto caption: Graphic by Krystal Abrigo.
York University’s Facing Backlash symposium builds solidarities in tough times
The symposium’s two packed days felt to me like the collective pursuit of an elusive, shape-shifting prey. But as participants shared experiences, and common-interest groups opened up their internal dialogue to the rest of the symposium, the contours of what we’re all up against started to come into focus for me, and I felt a collective sense of purpose growing.
iPhoto caption: Photo by Jae Yang.
REVIEW: Guillermo Verdecchia’s Feast is a fascinating text, but Tarragon’s new production feels hazy
I found the play really resonant and rich and layered. It’s about globalization, privilege, travel, displacement, and inequity, and it brought up many associations and past experiences for me. But I don’t feel that Soheil Parsa’s production fully comes together.
iPhoto caption: Photo by Marie-Andree Lemire.
REVIEW: Titaníque loves Céline Dion with all its heart
Content quibbles aside, Titaníque’s inarguable accomplishment is musical: What an amazing showcase for a Canadian cast’s vocal chops and capacity to deliver character through song.
Enter Stage Right: The Future of Intermission Magazine
Hello from the new leadership team of Intermission Magazine!
REVIEW: Festival TransAmériques — Weekend Two
Bonjour hi encore – et mon dieu, so many festivals!
Comments