REVIEW: The Play That Goes Wrong dazzles at Theatre Calgary
iPhoto caption: Photo courtesy of Theatre Calgary.
There are loud audiences, and then there was the opening night audience of Theatre Calgary’s The Play That Goes Wrong.
The evening was a sustained symphony of laughter, applause, gasps, and guffaws. And though I’ve never been a sports fan, sitting in the house of the company’s premiere production of their 2024/25 season, I started to see the appeal; there’s something uniquely uplifting about being surrounded by a crowd of people united by the common hope of seeing the players succeed.
An ambitious collaboration between Theatre Calgary, the Citadel Theatre, and the Royal Manitoba Theatre Centre, The Play That Goes Wrong, by British comedy trio Henry Lewis, Jonathan Sayer, and Henry Shields, follows the fictional production of “The Murder at Haversham Manor,” a 1920s, Christie-esque murder mystery chock-full of the usual suspects. From the moment the play begins, however, shit hits the fan. (Surprise!) What ensues is a thrumming two hours of comedy mayhem featuring a crumbling set, fumbled lines, and multiple performer casualties. We watch as the cast and crew scramble to put out metaphorical and literal fires, all in the effort of ensuring the show goes decidedly on.
If you need a reason to see The Play That Goes Wrong, let it be its incomparable design. The show’s got everything, from a towering, multi-level set to pyrotechnics, infinite props, and beyond. Set and prop designer Beyata Hackborn’s work is truly a brilliant piece of engineering. Designed to optically fail at every turn, what makes the design so impressive is its ability to malfunction safely. Actors confront relentless physical mishaps and yet, no one jumps up to help. Why? The design work is impenetrable and provides us little reason not to trust in it.
The same can be said for the show’s performances. Despite watching the actors stumble and flounder to no foreseeable end, the anxiety they face does not extend past the (in this case, very flimsy) fourth wall. This boils down to the razor-sharp intentionality that underscores the entire show. When things inevitably go wrong, we know it’s because they are meant to, and thanks to the steady mastery of the ensemble’s performance, we are given the privilege of leaving all doubts at the door.
A standout performer amongst the all-around stellar cast is Andrew MacDonald-Smith in the role of Max, the actor who plays both Cecil (the victim’s brother) and Arthur (the manor’s gardener). The character’s use of mnemonic gestures to get through large chunks of script is unexpected and hilarious. What is perhaps even more entertaining though, is his tendency to celebrate any and every onstage success he has. Whether jumping for joy or going for a first-row-long train of high fives, the opening night audience couldn’t help but share his delight, and MacDonald-Smith was the recipient of many rounds of applause throughout the evening.
I also feel compelled to mention Alexander Ariate, whose depiction of murder victim Charles is anything but lifeless. (With an eye toward discretion, I urge you to witness first-hand just what I mean.)
From one disaster to the next, director Dennis Garnhum proves an unshakeable pilot who steers the 2012 script with surety and rigor. As an audience member, it’s sometimes difficult to pinpoint where the script ends and the direction begins, but I believe it’s safe to say that the two operate in tandem. Punchy text paired with a shameless commitment to hilarity make for comedy crown jewels that even the most theatre-averse could enjoy.
And that’s what makes Theatre Calgary’s The Play That Goes Wrong such a strong season opener — its wide point of entry for audiences of just about any theatre background. In their second year of their “Theatre For All” initiative, the programming of this play positions the company firmly within its mandate. A metaplay with a paper-thin plot, The Play That Goes Wrong’s lack of structure and a reliance on pure humour fosters a performance that is fun and easy to digest. Even bits that are repeated over and over allow for a gradual learning curve while simultaneously creating a collective language in the room. The audience becomes a community that is “in” on the gag through the extended inside joke of a play we’re all privy to. It’s a clever tactic used to make you feel like a part of something larger than life, and it sure as hell works.
The Play That Goes Wrong is a sparking-flaming-smoking car crash that you just can’t take your eyes off of. A fiery, racing delight, this is not a production to be missed.
Intermission reviews are independent and unrelated to Intermission’s partnered content. Learn more about Intermission’s partnership model here.
Eve Beauchamp
Eve Beauchamp (they/them) is an award-winning Calgary-based theatre artist, playwright, and graduate of the BFA in Acting at the University of Ottawa. They are the co-artistic director of Levity Theatre Company and primarily create work that explores queerness, capitalism, and neurodivergence through humour, poetry, and storytelling. Currently, you can find them pursuing their Master of Fine Arts in Drama at the University of Calgary.
LEARN MORE
iPhoto caption: Photo by Dahlia Katz.
REVIEW: How does the American musical Waitress land in today’s Canada? It’s complicated
The Theatre Aquarius and Grand Theatre co-production is fascinating for its attempt to harness the pleasures of the Broadway musical form, while casting an awkward-stepping jaundiced eye at fantasies of American identity.
iPhoto caption: Photo by Dahlia Katz.
REVIEW: A Public Display of Affection simultaneously holds your hand and breaks your heart
Like a disco ball shimmering to a Donna Summer hit, playwright-performer Jonathan Wilson illuminates and refracts detailed memories about absent friends whose names, struggles, and lives have otherwise vanished, while walking through modern streets where a little gay hand-holding in Starbucks goes completely unnoticed.
iPhoto caption: Photo by Dahlia Katz.
REVIEW: Theatre Aquarius’ Fully Committed playfully satirizes the world of fine dining
The play’s back-and-forth premise makes for an excellent showcase of Gavin Crawford’s substantial comedic chops.
iPhoto caption: Photo by Damon McLean.
REVIEW: Riot King’s Red examines Rothko’s uncompromising legacy
While Red cannot unseal the legacy of its paintings, this iteration conjures an immense compassion for the arts workers who try.
iPhoto caption: Kayla Sakura Charchuk, Jay Leonard Juatco, Kimberly-Ann Truong, Jun Kung, and Raugi Yu in Cambodian Rock Band. Set design by Jung-Hye Kim, costume design by Stephanie Kong, lighting design by Itai Erdal. Photo by Moonrider Productions.
REVIEW: Cambodian Rock Band makes scintillating Canadian premiere at Vancouver’s Arts Club
Jumping back and forth through time, it weaves the story of a father-daughter relationship together with high-energy musical performances and meditations on the traumatic effects of the Cambodian genocide.
iPhoto caption: Photo of Tara Sky by Jeremy Mimnagh. Set design by Shannon Lea Doyle, costume design by Asa Benally, lighting design by Hailey Verbonac.
REVIEW: The Born-Again Crow is an ardent ode to unproductivity
Director Jessica Carmichael’s Toronto premiere production trucks along with the passionate force of an early-2000s emo rock hit, imbuing this systemic critique with rousing, playful life.
iPhoto caption: Photo by Nanc Price.
REVIEW: A Streetcar Named Desire pulls into Theatre Calgary for the first time in over two decades
You’ll find everything you might expect from a take on A Streetcar Named Desire: sensuality, top-notch performances, and all.
iPhoto caption: Photo by Trudie Lee.
A Christmas Carol makes a triumphant return to Theatre Calgary
“It brings me a lot of joy to know that the generations of Calgarians who saw this show when they were a young person are now, 37 years later, bringing their sons and daughters,” says artistic director Stafford Arima.
iPhoto caption: Photo by Ben Laird.
REVIEW: Twelve Days brings Christmas joy to lunchtime in Calgary
Watching Twelve Days is reminiscent of opening up the door to a chocolate advent calendar: yes, you know what you’re gonna get, but heck if you don’t enjoy every second of it.
iPhoto caption: The Lehman Trilogy production still by Trudie Lee.
REVIEW: Canadian theatre has a thing for The Lehman Trilogy. Does it work at Theatre Calgary?
The real drivers of Theatre Calgary’s production are its three performers. And boy, do they ever drive. Each performance pulses with unmatched and unrelenting vivacity, made all the more impressive by the stamina required from the ambitious three-and-a-half-hour runtime.
iPhoto caption: Photo by JVL Photography.
REVIEW: An unabashedly feminist Macbeth hits all the right notes in Ottawa
Kate Smith's pointed interpretation of the classic tragedy is a definite highlight and forecasts riveting things sure to be in store for Fools’ future programming.
iPhoto caption: Images courtesy of Ottawa Fringe.
For Trip the Light Collective, Ottawa Fringe ‘is a sandbox of creativity’
“Fringe is really like a sandbox for creativity,” says the award-winning collective. “[We’re] seeing where we can go outside of the box. It’s stories we want to tell and it's stories that reflect our experience.”
Comments